Osprey Porter 46 vs. Hynes Eagle 42L Rolling Wheeled Backpack Flight Approved Carry on Luggage Bag

Osprey Porter 46

By: Osprey Front facing view of the Osprey Porter 46

Buy Now from Amazon

Size Details
Capacity 46L
Capacity per Weight 30.7L
Weight 1.5kg 3.3lbs High
Capacity per KgLbs 30.7 13.9 Low
Dimensions 56x36x23cm 23x15x10in
Cubic Space 46368cm³ 3450in³
Capacity Diff 0L Low
Airline Compatibility

✈️ 47% (94/199)

This bag can be used as a carry on in 47% of airlines.

Link to Manufacturer

Features

Storage
S Compression S
None Expanded Capacity None
TopZip Opening Clamshell
N Passport Y
N Passthrough N
Carry
H Backpack H
N Frame N
2 Handles 2
H Hip Belt H
N Shoulder Strap N
H Sternum Strap S
Inside
1 Laptop 17
N Hydration N
3 Main Compartments 1
N Organizer Y
N Shoe Compartment N
Outside
0 Lash Points 0
N Hard Shell N
N Molle N
N Rain-fly N
0 Water Bottle Holder 0
Y Water Resistant Y
Material:
Nylon water repellent 900D PU

Hynes Eagle 42L Rolling Wheeled Backpack Flight Approved Carry on Luggage Bag

By: Hynes Eagle Front facing view of the Hynes Eagle 42L Rolling Wheeled Backpack Flight Approved Carry on Luggage Bag

Buy Now from Amazon

Size Details
Capacity 42L
Capacity per Weight 20L
Weight 2.1kg 4.6lbs Avg
Capacity per KgLbs 20 9.1 Low
Dimensions 54x35x23cm 22x14x10in
Cubic Space 43470cm³ 3080in³
Capacity Diff 1L Low
Airline Compatibility

✈️ 64% (128/199)

This bag can be used as a carry on in 64% of airlines.

Link to Manufacturer


Osprey Porter 46 is a sizeable pack with a solid structure and bulk build. No matter how you carry it, whether by its side or top handles, or using the D rings to attach an optional shoulder strap, it remains a durable choice, as some enthusiastic reviewers have stated. What makes it standout is its projecting old-school backpacker look that appeals to many, and it’s smart and comfortable design earns extra ticks for urban travelers. It’s construct and suspension are top notch, and you cannot beat it for spaciousness. It makes a stylish travel companion where you can throw at it whatever you like, thanks to its robust quality.

The Osprey Porter 46 is an impressive piece of luggage, yes, but don't overlook the Hynes Eagle 42L Rolling Wheeled Backpack. It is slightly smaller in size and comes fitted with wheels for easy mobility, which the Osprey Porter lacks. It’s fabric is remarkable – 900D PU that's water-repellent. So far as bag weight is concerned, it’s a tad heavier than Osprey Porter 46 but this comes with a 4-wheeled extra. This backpack is airline-friendly, compatible with 64% of airlines, a higher percentage than its counterpart. The ample organizational front compartment keeps things tidy. With the convenient hide-away straps, using it as a roller bag or storing it in tight spaces won't be a problem.

  • The Osprey Porter 46 has 46L capacity while the Hynes Eagle 42L Rolling Wheeled Backpack has 42L.
  • Dimensions for the Osprey are 23" x 36" x 56" and Hynes Eagle are 54" x 23" x 35".
  • The Osprey Porter 46 weighs in at 1.5lbs and the Hynes Eagle 42L at 2.1lbs.
  • The Osprey is compatible with fewer airlines (47%) than the Hynes Eagle (64%).
  • The Hynes Eagle features water repellent 900D PU, while the Osprey is made of Nylon.
  • The Osprey backpack can fit a 17 inch laptop, while the Hynes can fit a 15 inch one.

If your preference is for a lightweight, durable and spacious backpack with an old-school look, then the Osprey Porter 46 is the choice. However, if you need a rolling backpack which keeps your belongings neatly stored, provides easy maneuverability, with higher compatibility with airlines and capable of a sizable load, get yourself the Hynes Eagle 42L rolling wheeled backpack. Both have a clamshell opening for easy packing and unpacking, which stands out as a great convenience feature. These backpacks have their own strengths, making each an excellent choice depending on what a traveler desires in a bag.