Osprey Porter 46 vs. 5.11 Rush 12

Osprey Porter 46

By: Osprey Front facing view of the Osprey Porter 46

Buy Now from Amazon

Size Details
Capacity 46L
Capacity per Weight 30.7L
Weight 1.5kg 3.3lbs High
Capacity per KgLbs 30.7 13.9 Low
Dimensions 56x36x23cm 23x15x10in
Cubic Space 46368cm³ 3450in³
Capacity Diff 0L Low
Airline Compatibility

✈️ 47% (94/199)

This bag can be used as a carry on in 47% of airlines.

Link to Manufacturer

Features

Storage
S Compression N
None Expanded Capacity None
TopZip Opening TopZip
N Passport N
N Passthrough N
Carry
H Backpack S
N Frame N
2 Handles 1
H Hip Belt R
N Shoulder Strap N
H Sternum Strap R
Inside
1 Laptop 15
N Hydration N
3 Main Compartments 16
N Organizer N
N Shoe Compartment N
Outside
0 Lash Points 4
N Hard Shell N
N Molle S
N Rain-fly N
0 Water Bottle Holder 0
Y Water Resistant Y
Material:
Nylon Water-resistant 1050D nylon

5.11 Rush 12

By: 5.11 Tactical Front facing view of the 5.11 Rush 12

Buy Now from Amazon

Size Details
Capacity 24L
Capacity per Weight 20L
Weight 1.2kg 2.6lbs High
Capacity per KgLbs 20 9.2 Low
Dimensions 46x28x17cm 18x11x6.5in
Cubic Space 21896cm³ 1287.0in³
Capacity Diff -2L Low
Airline Compatibility

✈️ 100% (198/199)

This bag can be used as a carry on in 100% of airlines.

Link to Manufacturer


Both the Osprey Porter 46 and the 5.11 Rush 12 are solid choices for carrying your essentials. The Osprey Porter 46, a spacious pack designed to contain everything from travel gear to camping essentials, has an impressive 46-liter capacity. Its main feature is its size; towering at up to 23 inches tall, it's a beast of a bag that doesn't skimp on storage space. Made of robust Nylon, this pack is lightweight for its size, weighing only 1.5 pounds. You won't have to worry about it taking up too much of your airline weight allowance.

The Osprey Porter 46 offers admirable functionality, with its clamshell opening for quick packing and unpacking, and compression straps to keep everything neat. It's a bag for those who need a bit more room. The Osprey Porter 46's laptop compartment can fit a laptop of up to 1 inch, making it great for both business and leisure travelers. It is compatible with 47% of airlines, so you may want to check whether your regular airlines are included before you purchase this pack.

On the other hand, the 5.11 Rush 12 is a robust and resilient pack, standing at a towering 46 inches tall. It's smaller than the Osprey Porter 46 in terms of capacity, offering 24 liters of space, but what it lacks in size it more than makes up for in durability and ruggedness. Made of Water-resistant 1050D nylon, this pack weighs slightly less than the Osprey Porter 46 at 1.2 pounds and is accepted on 100% of airlines.

The 5.11 Rush 12 is not just tough – it's adaptable. With multiple attachments available for the molle webbing, you can tailor this pack to your specific needs. Its front compartment is incredibly spacious and can fit items like a 500ml water bottle, among other things. Much like the Porter 46, the Rush 12 also has a laptop compartment, attentive to tech-savvy travelers, able to comfortably house a 15-inch laptop.

Comparison of Osprey Porter 46 and the 5.11 Rush 12:

  • Size: The Osprey Porter 46 is smaller in height but offers more width and depth compared to the 5.11 Rush 12.
  • Weight: The Osprey Porter 46 is slightly heavier than the 5.11 Rush 12.
  • Capacity: The Porter 46 has 46 liters of storage capacity, doubling the 24 liters offered by the Rush 12.
  • Material: While the Porter 46 is made with Nylon, Rush 12 is built with Water-resistant 1050D nylon.
  • Laptop Compartment: The Osprey Porter 46 can accommodate a 1-inch laptop, whereas the Rush 12 can fit a 15-inch laptop.
  • Airline Compatibility: The Porter 46 is compatible with 47% of airlines, while the Rush 12 boasts 100% compatibility.
  • Reviewer Metrics: Most reviewers praise the spaciousness and durability of the Porter 46, whereas the Rush 12 receives high marks for its ruggedness and customization options.

Both the Osprey Porter 46 and the 5.11 Rush 12 bring unique attributes to the table, but your final decision should ultimately depend on your specific needs and preferences.