Osprey Porter 46 vs. Millican Miscellaneous Adventures

Two carry-on travel backpacks, compared spec for spec.

Osprey Porter 46

Front facing view of the Osprey Porter 46
Capacity46 L
Weight1.5 kg
Dimensions56×36×23 cm
Airline fit47%
Price$150

Feature by feature

Osprey Porter 46FeatureMillican Miscellaneous Adventures
Storage
S Compression
None Expanded Capacity None
4 Opening 0
N Passport side
N Passthrough N
Carry
H Backpack
H Hip Belt N
H Sternum Strap N
Inside
1 Laptop 15
3 Main Compartments 3
N Organizer N
Outside
× Hard Shell ×
N Rain-fly N
0 Water Bottle Holder
Y Water Resistant Y
Material
Nylon100% recycled polyester made from 40 PET bottlesC6 DWR water repellent treatmentPU1500 waterproof coating

Millican Miscellaneous Adventures

Front facing view of the Millican Miscellaneous Adventures
Capacity18 L
Weight1 kg
Dimensions51×29×13 cm
Airline fit98%
Price$110

The Osprey Porter 46 is a believer in space and capacity. Built to meet the needs of those who have a lot to carry, the Porter measures larger with a height of 23 inches, width of 36 inches, and a depth of 56 inches. Despite its sizable form, it manages to stay lightweight at 1.5 pounds, which makes it easier for you to haul your load without sweating the weight. Made of durable nylon and packed with a hefty 46 liters of capacity, this bag offers you plenty of room to stuff in your gear, souvenirs, or anything that you might pick up on your travels. This bag doesn't compromise on organization either. It comes with a laptop compartment for a sizeable 17 inches, keeping your digital companion safe and sound.

Contrarily, the Millican Miscellaneous Adventures takes a different approach. This bag is a different animal altogether. Going by measurements, it stands tall at 51 inches, a more Japan-friendly width of 29 inches, and a depth of 13 inches. The most striking difference between the Miscellaneous Adventures and the Porter 46 is in terms of weight. Weighing in at a single pound, the Miscellaneous Adventures is a lightweight companion, ideal for globetrotting minimalists. With a lower 18 liters of capacity, it forces you to pack smart, eliminate the unnecessary, and focus on what's truly essential. This bag is also kind to the environment, constructed of 100% recycled polyester.

Let's do some meat-and-bones comparison between the two bags:

Stepping into the review aspect, the two bags have received rave reviews for their qualities. The Porter 46 seems to be a favorite amongst those who prefer a larger load-out, with reviewers stating that it is a durable option that can be bulked or cinched down depending on needs. The Miscellaneous Adventures has received praise for its eco-conscious material choice and its versatility. Reviewers have also touched on its compatibility with more airlines, making the Miscellaneous Adventures a hassle-free travel companion.

In summary, if your travel gear tends to pile up and you don't want to fret about stuff spilling out, the Osprey Porter 46 is your best bet. Alternatively, if you adhere to a "less is more" packing philosophy and admire sustainable products, the Millican Miscellaneous Adventure would be a bag worth looking into. The best bag depends on your travel gear tendencies, so choose wisely.