Osprey Porter 46 vs. Timbuk2 Aviator

Two carry-on travel backpacks, compared spec for spec.

Osprey Porter 46

Front facing view of the Osprey Porter 46
Capacity46 L
Weight1.5 kg
Dimensions55×36×23 cm
Airline fit61%
Price$185

Feature by feature

Osprey Porter 46FeatureTimbuk2 Aviator
Storage
2 Compression
None Expanded Capacity None
1 Opening 0
top Passport
Y Passthrough
Carry
hideable Backpack
hideable Hip Belt
Y Sternum Strap
Inside
16in Laptop
4 Main Compartments 0
Y Organizer
Outside
× Hard Shell ×
N Rain-fly
N Water Bottle Holder
Y Water Resistant
Material
bluesign®-approved Recycled 500D Nylon Packcloth PFC Free DWR

Timbuk2 Aviator

Front facing view of the Timbuk2 Aviator
Capacity30 L
Weight2 kg
Dimensions58×39×24 cm
Airline fit4%
Price$166

Key differences between the Osprey Porter 46 and Timbuk2 Aviator

Which airlines take each bag as a carry-on

We checked both bags against the carry-on size limits of 189 airlines. 7 accept both. 109 accept only the Osprey Porter 46, and 0 accept only the Timbuk2 Aviator.

Only the Osprey Porter 46 fits

Adria Airways, Aegean Airlines, Aer Lingus, Aeroflot, Aeromexico, Air Asia, Air Astana, Air Canada, Air Caraibes, Air Europa, Air Koryo, Air Macau, Air New Zealand, Air Nostrum, Air Tahiti Nui, Air Wisconsin, AirAsiaX, Alaska Airlines, All Nipon Airways, Allegiant Air, American Airlines, ANA, Atlas Global, Austrian, Avianca , Azerbaijan Airlines, Azul Linhas, Bahamasair, Bangkok Airways, Biman Bangladesh, British Airways, Brussels Airlines, Cambodia Angkor Air, Caribbean Airlines, Cathay Pacific, Cebu Pacific, China Airlines, China Southern, CommutAir, Conviasa, Copa Airlines, Cubana de Aviacion, Czech Airlines, Delta Airlines, Dragonair, EL AL, Ethiopian Airlines, Eurowings, EVA Air, Fiji Airways, Finnair, Flair Air, Garuda Indonesia, Gol Linhas Aereas, Hainan Airlines, Hawaiian Airlines, Hong Kong Airlines, Iberia, Interjet, Iran Air, Iran Aseman Air, Japan Airlines, Jet2, jetBlue Airways, Jetstar Airways, Jetstar Asia, Korean Air, Kulula, Kuwait Air, LOT Polish, Lufthansa, Mahan Air, Malaysia Airlines, Mango, Mesa Airlines, Middle East Airlines, Monarch Airlines, Norwegian, Onur Air, Peach, Philippine Airlines, Porter Airlines, Qantas Airways, Republic Airways, Royal Air Morocco, SAS Scandinavian, Saudi Arabian Airlines, Sichuan Airlines, SilkAir, Silver Airways, Singapore Airlines, Skywest, Inc., South African Airways, SpiceJet, Spirit Airlines, SriLankan Airlines, Swiss Int'l Air Lines, TAAG Angola, TAM Airlines, Thai Airways, Trans States, Travel Service Airlines, Turkish Airlines, United Airlines, Ural Airlines, Uzbekistan Air, Vietnam Airlines, Virgin Atlantic, WOW Airlines.

The Osprey Porter 46 by Osprey and the Timbuk2 Aviator by Thule are both commendable carry-on backpack options. They both offer excellent durability and construction meant for the long haul - made for those who live their lives on the move, across cities or continents. Each has its wide range of positives and unique selling points, but also features that set them apart.

The Osprey Porter 46 is larger in size and lighter in weight than its counterpart, the Timbuk2 Aviator. However, the Aviator, despite being slightly heavier and smaller in size, wins points for wider compatibility with airlines (91% compared to Porter's 47%). The Porter 46 also comes equipped with a laptop compartment, unlike the Aviator. The choice boils down to what matters most to you, be it airline compatibility, weight, size, or specific features like a laptop compartment.

Comparison:

Reviews about the Porter 46 reveal much admiration for this big capacious backpack, praising its durability and its versatility as a deluxe duffel or a portable backpack. It is the choice for those seeking a mid-sized bag — durable and comfortable — designed with the urban traveler in mind. However, the absence of review comments on the Aviator leaves some questions to be answered - what highlights and flaws does it hide?

The Porter 46 is a top choice, and not without reason. It provides excellent suspension, has ample storage space, and its construction ensures that your gear remains safe. Moreover, it's lightweight despite its size, making it a delight to carry around. The easy clamshell opening allows for convenient packing and unpacking, and the compression strap ensures your bag never looks sloppy, regardless of how much you stuff inside. The decision, however, is yours to make — comparing and weighing the trade-offs between the Aviator and the Porter 46.